Salt Lake City, Utah — A bill moving through the Utah Legislature would force government-owned nursing homes to spend far more of their Medicaid dollars on residents — and far less on everything else.
The draft legislation, which cleared committee with just two dissenting votes, targets facilities that participate in the federal Upper Payment Limit program. That program has funneled more than $1 billion in supplemental Medicaid payments to government-run nursing homes nationwide over the past decade, and Utah facilities have leaned on it heavily.
Why lawmakers stepped in
The push follows a state audit released in April that raised eyebrows across the state. Auditors found participating nursing homes spent only 49% of the federal Medicaid funds they received from 2016 through 2024. The other 51%? It went to owner compensation, administrative costs, and hospital operating expenses.
Under the bill, those facilities would need to direct at least 70% of revenue to direct patient care starting January 2028. Qualifying spending covers services and supplies tied to residents’ physical, behavioral, social, and clinical needs. Rent, capital improvements, management fees unrelated to care, and non-nursing administrative costs wouldn’t count.
The legislation also writes minimum staffing standards into law for UPL-funded homes. Facilities would need to average 3.6 hours of direct care per resident daily — two hours from certified nursing assistants and one from licensed nurses. Ratio rules follow too: one CNA per 20 residents, one nurse per 40. It’s the kind of accountability advocates have pushed for elsewhere, and Medicaid dollars flowing into nursing homes have drawn scrutiny from federal watchdogs in other states.
Support and skepticism
Supporters, including the Disability Law Center, argue the requirements simply ensure taxpayer money reaches the residents it was meant for. The center has flagged chronic understaffing at participating facilities.
Not everyone is convinced. During floor debate, Sen. Jerry Stevenson, a Republican from Layton, acknowledged some facilities fall short on care quality but warned mandates could backfire in rural Utah, where workforce shortages already run deep.
“Some care is better than no care,” Stevenson said, suggesting facilities in remote areas might simply close rather than comply.
The bill now heads toward the full legislative session, which begins January 19. If it passes, Utah would join a small group of states attaching hard strings to supplemental Medicaid payments — and operators everywhere will be watching how it plays out.


