Saturday, November 14

Indianapolis, Indiana — Nursing homes across Indiana lost out on $205.2 million in Medicaid supplemental payments that were supposed to boost their reimbursement, according to a federal audit released this week. Instead, county hospitals that own most of the state’s facilities recouped the money for themselves.

The report from the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General paints a picture of a funding stream so murky that even federal watchdogs struggle to follow the dollars. In total, the OIG found that nearly half of Indiana’s supplemental payments — $479.8 million — ended up with nonstate government-owned entities such as county hospitals. Of that sum, $274.6 million represented the state share those entities had initially contributed to the program.

Here’s why that matters: during the audit period, roughly 97% of Indiana’s nursing facilities were operated by county-owned hospitals. That arrangement gave them access to extra Medicaid funding available only to government-owned homes. Critics have long argued the setup channels money meant for resident care into hospital operations instead.

Why Indiana drew federal attention

The state wasn’t picked at random. Indiana received the highest nursing facility supplemental payments in the nation in fiscal 2022 — about $1.02 billion of the $2.36 billion reported nationwide, according to the audit. A 2020 investigation by the Indianapolis Star also helped prompt the review, after the paper reported that much of the money was funding county hospital operations rather than reaching the nursing homes themselves.

“Federal oversight of Medicaid supplemental payments has long been a concern because of their complexity, scale, and limited transparency,” the report stated. The payments often lack provider-level detail, the OIG added, which obscures how taxpayer dollars are actually used.

The audit also flagged sloppy accounting on the state’s end. Indiana failed to report overpayments, included an extra day in leap-year calculations, and used an incorrect federal matching rate. The OIG determined the state claimed $12.2 million in federal payments that didn’t comply with federal and state requirements.

What happens next

Auditors issued four recommendations, including that Indiana explore ways to increase the share of supplemental payments actually retained by participating nursing facilities — and refund the $12.2 million in excess payments to the federal government.

The transparency problem isn’t limited to one state. A 2019 Senate Finance Committee report flagged similar concerns nationwide, and watchdogs continue to press for provider-level detail on where these billions actually land. Federal officials have already pushed for tighter pay transparency across nursing home funding, and this report adds fresh weight to that argument. For residents and operators watching Medicaid dollars vanish between the statehouse and the bedside, the question now is whether Indiana — and Congress — act on the findings.


Discover more from Skilled Care Journal

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share.
Leave A Reply