A federal program designed to keep frail older adults living at home — rather than in nursing facilities — works, according to a sweeping new policy analysis. But it’s reaching less than half a percent of the people who actually qualify for it.
The Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) integrates Medicare and Medicaid into a single, coordinated care model that delivers medical, social, and daily living services to adults 55 and older who would otherwise require nursing home-level care. According to research published in the Journal of Advanced Nursing in March, PACE participants are hospitalized less often, visit emergency rooms less frequently, and tend to live longer in their communities before needing institutional care.
“Through fully capitated financing and interdisciplinary service delivery, PACE enables older adults to remain at home, maintain autonomy, and receive coordinated, high-quality care,” the authors wrote.
The findings reinforce what long-term care advocates have argued for years — that the right model, properly funded, can shift the center of gravity away from institutional care. As policymakers continue debating how value-based care models should reach nursing homes, PACE stands out as a model with a two-decade track record. The catch: it’s still not available to most of the people who need it.
As of 2024, PACE enrolled roughly 56,000 participants nationwide — less than 0.5% of potentially eligible older adults. The program requires dual eligibility for both Medicare and Medicaid, immediately cutting out anyone enrolled in Medicare alone. And because PACE centers must be physically present in the communities they serve, rural and underserved areas are largely left without access.
Racial and ethnic disparities in enrollment compound the problem. The analysis found that Black and Hispanic older adults are significantly underrepresented in PACE despite being more likely to qualify based on health status and income. Authors tied the gap to structural barriers — transportation, language, and a lack of PACE sites in minority communities.
The Cost Problem
It’s not just an equity issue. PACE’s Medicare capitation rates average about 20% more per beneficiary than comparable Medicare Advantage plans, raising concerns among policymakers about long-term scalability. Despite higher per-person costs, the program still produces savings when measured against what full-time nursing home care would cost — but that argument has proven harder to sell to budget writers focused on per-member spending.
The analysis also found that 78% of PACE enrollees remain in nonprofit programs as of 2022, suggesting that broader ownership diversification — often seen as a path to faster growth — hasn’t meaningfully expanded capacity.
Workforce shortages round out the picture. PACE depends heavily on nurses who can coordinate care across settings, and the same staffing crisis affecting nursing homes is hitting PACE providers too. Without enough qualified staff, new PACE sites are harder to open and existing sites struggle to take on new participants.
What Needs to Change
The study authors called for expanding eligibility to Medicare-only populations, building out geographic access — especially in rural regions — and addressing the financial misalignments that limit growth. They also pushed for stronger equity data collection and targeted outreach to underserved communities.
For nursing home operators, the analysis is a reminder that PACE and skilled nursing care aren’t necessarily competitors. Many PACE participants eventually transition into nursing facilities as their needs increase. But the smaller that transition gap stays — and the later it happens — the better the outcome for residents and the healthcare system alike.
Discover more from Skilled Care Journal
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


