Friday, November 20

Rochester, New York — A wave of abrupt nursing home closures is now colliding with a second wave: class-action lawsuits from the workers those facilities left behind.

The latest case involves Waterview Heights Rehabilitation and Nursing Center, where more than 200 former employees allege they never got the advance notice of closure that state law requires. The facility shut down in September after years of regulatory problems and state oversight, according to local reports, and one certified nurse aide learned of the closure during a late-August meeting — then was terminated six days later.

It’s not an isolated fight. In St. Louis, workers at a nursing home that closed overnight in late 2023 won a $2 million judgment after owners ran out of money mid-closure, forcing the relocation of more than 170 residents. As of October, the owners agreed to pay roughly $365,000 to 184 employees, their attorneys and the payout administrator — about one-fifth of what the court awarded.

A gap in the shutdown playbook

Attorneys who work with long-term care providers say closures are treated almost exclusively as a resident-care and regulatory problem, while the people on payroll get forgotten until it’s too late.

“Over the past few years, I certainly have seen an increase in nursing homes closing,” said Ellie Tucker, a partner at Hall Render Killian Heath and Lyman in Indianapolis. She said recent newsworthy cases should serve as cautionary tales for providers weighing a shutdown.

Under federal law, an administrator who fails to give a state survey agency 60 days’ notice of closure — or approval for a relocation plan — can face a personal fine of up to $100,000, adjusted upward for inflation. Yet one Chicago health care attorney argues the penalty targets the wrong person: it lands on the hired administrator rather than the operators or building owners who actually make the call, and it’s imposed so rarely that most operators don’t know it exists.

There’s also the WARN Act, the federal worker-notice law enforced almost entirely through private litigation. New York’s version required Waterview Heights to give staff 90 days’ warning — which is exactly why employees, not regulators, are the ones suing.

Financial distress makes it worse

The facilities most likely to close are also the ones least able to wind down in an orderly way. Tucker said operators without forward-looking financial projections often find themselves unable to make payroll, and that’s when closures turn chaotic — creating regulatory exposure and inviting exactly the kind of private lawsuits now emerging.

Providers who start planning while they still have financial runway can protect residents, notify employees and regulators properly, and cut the risk of ending up in court, she said. The cost of ignoring employment obligations, as a Texas verdict earlier this year showed, can run into the millions.


Discover more from Skilled Care Journal

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share.
Leave A Reply